I found myself emulating the same big smile that was plastered on Ash's face most of the time just out of sheer enjoyment of the interaction between the characters. Seriously- I had to rub my face to get my smile to relax! This game was so fun to play through. Each of the characters where so uniquely characterized I just ended up loving all the boys for their own respective reasons. Hearing Paris's theme music always puts a big dumb grin on my face though so I guess he's fav.
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
I just made an account so I could comment here. This game...I've only played about half an hour of it, and I will probably add a more in depth review when I've finished it, but I just have to say....the characterizations are so engaging. And funny. I've lol'ed 3 times already. Excellent job with the writing. (Though, in future projects, consider using a slightly more bold font, it can get a little hard on the eyes!)
thank you so much for your comments! I’m really glad you’re enjoying it so far. You can change the font from the main menu ^^
thanks, I found it! and I finished Paris' route - I can't believe you did all of the writing, art, and music, this is AMAZING. kudos, I'm so impressed! (and looking forward to seeing future projects from you!)
So happy you liked it! I hope you enjoy future projects just as much ^^ I'll be adding in the rest of the voices over the course of the next few months, and chapter 1 should have full voice by the end of January, so keep an eye out if you'd like that update! Paris' VA does an excellent job!
why i can't play rafael rout .......... i mean it's unable to choose him and i want to play HIS ROUTE please somone tell me haw can i get the access to rafael route please ??
You can play Rafael’s route if you’re a cubi or a shika, he’s not romanceable as a reaver. Let me know if you have any problems!
The best things in life are mushroom-free ;) <3 <3 <3
I absolutely love this game and I just started playing! I do have one question though: I finished one version of Paris and Rafael but I seem to be unable to choose Braums, how do you access his route?
You can play Braums' route as a Shika, or a Reaver! Thanks so much for playing and I'm glad you enjoyed. Hopefully you'll like Braums' route just as much!
i want to donate so that i can get the art book but it wont let me.
Hello! There is currently no art book for The Pretenders Guild. I've thought about making one but decided to move on to other projects.
i've had an account on itch for quite a while (at least two years?) and yet this is the first time i've commented on a game.
i played through the whole thing (all endings and all possible species, though not all genders) in two days, and i enjoyed
almost every minute of it. the pacing was just right, the tension, ash's inner monologue... the only things i regret are the order in which i played the routes, and that i didn't do my usual visual novel practice of aiming for the bad endings first, and those are both my own fault. the latter is a testament to how much i was enjoying it, though - i didn't want the bad endings. but, alas, i am a completionist.
i also had waaaay to much fun with the customization options. i don't know how other people play, but i had a distinctly different appearance for each "ash" - my first "ash" was a shika with the medium skintone, black hair, and brown eyes; cubi!ash had the darker skintone, pink hair, and blue eyes; and reaver!ash had the pale skintone, silver hair, and red eyes. part of it for me, i think, is that i have brainweird and having that stark of a visible difference between them helps me remember which "ash" i'm playing as. but i'm also just a sucker for character customizers.
i played paris's route last. (i should have just played them in top-to-bottom order from the selection screen! dangit, past me!) but my first playthrough was shika!ash, so paris wasn't an option then and i have so many regreeeets. i loved that there were different endings for braums's route depending on what species you chose
(and i love that reaver!ash is a snobby little shit sometimes), and that there are little interactions with everyone that change depending on which "ash" you're playing. i'm definitely a detail person, and stopping my skip-throughs as a different species to see how the dialogue had changed was always fun.
my personal favorite route was rafael's. it was the first route i played, so naturally it'll have that special place, but i think it'd still be my favorite regardless. i found it interesting how ash interacted with a love interest of their own species versus one of a different species, as well - for example, i liked rafael's route better overall when playing as shika!ash (i found the shared cultural moments really touching, because it was something neither of them had ever really had someone to share it with), but i really liked playing paris's with reaver!ash (perhaps because reaver!ash comes with considerably more snark - not that ash is ever lacking in the snark department).
overall - i dunno, it was okay, i guess.
pfff, i sure hope you can tell i loved it. i might even wipe my save and replay it sometime. need to wait for the emotional scars from my last run to heal first, though. god and in the good end! you know! [spoiler] wouldn't have [spoiler]ed ash! so that [spoiler] wasn't even necessary!!! why'd you have to do that to me that hurted.
This really made my day! Thanks so much for leaving such an in depth comment, so glad you enjoyed. Snobby reaver!ash is definitely one of my favorite Ash iterations xD
Thanks for playing!
So question, whats the neutral ending for Rafael, because i only had 5% with him at the end and i got the same thing i did before.
Rafael has two endings, his "best" ending, and a more neutral ending. The neutral end is the end where he comes back a few years later. To get his best end, you have to have %80 with him by the end of chapter 4!
I created this account to specifically ask if there was a list of sorts that said the endings and what they were(good,neutral,bad) and if there were any walkthroughs to get each ending. (i like to 100% complete all games XD)
I've started playing and I'm not very far yet, but I'm having A LOT of trouble navigating the game. I can't click choices at all, I have to use the arrow keys to move from option to option, and it always goes down to the mini menu instead of the third option, so I can never choose it. It made character creation a problem, as well. No one else seems to be having this problem though? I'm going to try downloading it again and see if I just got a bugged version or something.
I'm really sorry about that! I haven't heard of this error before. Please let me know if redownloading doesn't help! In the meantime, I'll see if I can find any issues on my end. Are you playing on windows, linux, or mac?
Thanks for responding so fast! Redownloading didn't help, but my saves were still there so maybe I should try again with a more thorough uninstall... anyway, I'm using the unvoiced linux version.
Hello! I just wanted to ask if you're still having issues. Have you tried launching the game through the itch.io app?
hello! i literally just made an account to tell you how amazing this game is!
first of all,the soundtrack is awesome,i usually turn off the music in games but i loved this one so so much!
also,i adore all of the characters,but my favorites definitely have to be Paris and Rafael! my favorite Ash is the male Shika,i would have loved to romance Paris as a Shika just to see how Paris would have reacted to Ash' hands being so sensible,but then again he probably already knew,i'm sure he slept with a Shika before lmao. can i ask if the routes that we weren't able to play now will be playable in the future ? (like Braum's route as a Cubi etc)
my favorite endings are ending 4 and 5,i know that number 4 is Rafael's "bad" ending but i really liked it anyway,i think it's kinda romantic that they still haven't forgotten about each other,idk.
anyway yeah,i love your game!
Thanks so much, I'm so glad you enjoyed! You're too kind ;u;b
I think Rafael's "bad" end is my favorite of his ends as well!
Unfortunately, I don't have plans to make those routes playable as of now.
Same I would love Ash Shika with Paris <3
so i was wondering, since "Pretenders Guild" and "Guild Guild" are both voiced, is there any other name that's voiced?
The voices are just TOP!)) love the actors, cant pick a favorite)))
On the tech side - sometimes Ashes voice (#3) is a lot quieter than the music and every other voice( Even with the sliders in the settings turned to min-max their voices(
And there's no choice anymore to open/give back Braums his note?
I’m so glad you enjoy! Voice 3 was quieter, I tried to raise the volume on her lines so I’ll go through one more time, I must have missed some!
As for Braum’s note, if you say you were /weren’t cheating in the beginning, the option doesn’t show up, I believe. Let me know if it still doesn’t show up after picking the other option!
Love this game! Thoroughly enjoying playing it again with this update :D
Did notice some bugs though(Spoilers ahead for those who haven't played yet or aren't up to Chapter 5):
- On the ship, when speaking with the children playing with marbles the wrong audio is played. When the boy asks Ash to teach him, the audio "Thanks Ash!" plays instead and nothing plays when we reach that line.
- In the cabin during the pirate attack, an error pops up:
File "game/chapter1.rpy", line 1823, in <module>
NameError: name 'guilde_name' is not defined
- Last bug I found was during the attack at camp. I've forgotten the exact moment, but during the bandits' conversation with each other multiple audios are played over one another.
In case it's important, I found these bugs while playing as a male Reaver pursuing Paris.
Oooh, thank you for those bug fixes! I'll snag those asap. c:
I'm glad you enjoyed!
I love this game. Great work. c:
Pretenders Guild is brilliant ! :) I were surprised by how polished the story and characters are. I liked how different background affects dialogue here and there, it encourages me to read through once more, instead of skipping. Rafael is so cuteeee, Braums is cute tooo, now I'm torn between finishing Paris or wait for the update, ahaha xD
Again, nicely done!
Thank you, I'm so glad you enjoyed! I recommend waiting for the update, Paris' VA did an awesome job!
just finished playing playing paris and braums routes, and loved it. But now i wanted to play rafael route but it doesn´t let me choose him. what do i have to do?
Hello! Thanks so much for playing, I’m glad you enjoyed. Rafael’s route is available as either a cubi or a shika.
I love Even more now there is voice acting XD male ash voices Are AWESOME XD suits them,Awesome work on the game and good job voice actors <3! (Well Will be voice acting XD sorry)
Love this game and the art. Music is awesome and the endings are really cute but I'm pretty sad about what happens to Rafael when it isn't his ending you get ;( Still, it's pretty fun hahaha
I absolutely love this game<3
I'm totally enamored by my sweet boi Braums (even though I feel slightly bad about stealing him from Paris, but all is fair in love and war).
The changes from race to race were an extremely pleasing surprise, the absolute sass of ma boi Ash was (fortunalety) unchangeable no matter if he was an fluffy bunny, "horny" boi or former member of the high society. My favorite race was the Reaver (specially in Paris's route), soon followed by the Shika (Braums) and the Cubi (Rafael).
I completed all the eight routes in less than six hours, changed the background more than ten times because I couldn't decide which one I loved more and used the soundtrack (which was amazing, by the way) as study music.
Also, I'm shocked that I haven't found any fanfiction of this lovely VN, absolutely shocked!
Haha I'm glad you enjoyed it! I tried to keep Ash's underlying personality the same even as his background gave him a different world view.
The day I find fan fiction for this VN will be the day my life is complete xD
I adore this game <3 Favourite route was the Rafael and Shika Ash route. (I love all the routes to bits)
It was.. well, it was cool)) Hilarious and very interesting)_))))Place this game at Steam and I'll buy it, immediately)
Thank you! I’m hoping to try and put it on steam once all the voices are finished. But no need to buy it, it will remain free ^^
Why not? I want to be fair - you created game, I thank you by buying it. If you'll ask me it's the best option to show affection about game and gratitude towards creators. If you'll see people love your game I think you would want to create another one, wouldn't you?)
I just finished my first run of this game and... wow. I did Braums' route and got Ending 6. Is that the best ending I can get in his route?
OMG this game was... AMAZING ! I don't have words to tell how much I liked it... I was a bit confused by the gameplay at first but I think this way of choosing emotions is really great and original ! And you can really choose how you are feeling ! I choosed male reaver Ash and I first wanted to go to Rafael (the kind of character I love to pursue) but as I couldn't I just went to Paris and, you know, chosing reaver Ash was the best "mistake" I ever made ! I LOVE Paris so much ! And in fact, I really think that his story with Ash is really smooth going, it seems logical, it's well written, all fall into place ! It suits my vision of my character so much that I couldn't help but LOVE it. I think I just would have wanted a bit of a deeper review of their years together when they were children but that's not a big deal, really.
Anyways, good job, I love your game, I love Paris, and I enjoyed playing that reaver Ash !
I'm glad you warmed up to the gameplay! I was a little worried people wouldn't like it. And I'm glad you ended up liking Paris, too xD yes, I don't talk a lot about their childhood, I probably could have spent a little more time on that. thanks so much for playing!
Don't worry this game is in my top favourite now so it didn't bother me a lot :D
And yeah, this gameplay was amazing ! Feel proud about having this idea ;)
Ps : Looking forward to you new game !
Let me say, this game was ABSOLUTELY fantastic, to the point where I am genuinely surprised that its completely free...Ash, no matter their race is a fucking riot. All of the routes were enjoyable (of course, I always have a soft spot for the literal thinker types cough
spock cough) and I didn't see many comments on it, but the soundtrack is absolute fire, the music is completely appropriate and fun for a fantasy setting without being vague generic fantasy noise, and I adore it. It's one of the few VNs that I really wanted to complete every route for, and i did not regret it one bit. Amazing job Minyan.
Thank you so much for the kind comments! Yes, I love spock—I mean, literal thinkers too xD definitely some inspiration from my favorite vulcan. I hope you enjoyed the other routes just as much! I was really worried about the soundtrack because I wouldn't exactly call myself a composer, so I'm happy to hear you enjoyed x3
Thanks again, this really made my day!
So...I found this game through Mnemonic Devices, and...I may have played it too much. I found it less than 24 hours ago, and I already got all eight endings. ^_^;
Braums was adorable, and by far my favorite. I almost feel bad stealing him from Paris, though, because their romance in the Extras was really cute, too. Still, Braums is mine, and I'm not sharing him! :P
I will also echo someone else's complaint about Ash's anti-vegetarian attitude, being vegetarian myself, but I still really liked the game.
xD Ash has very strong opinions about meat, I'm sorry.
I'm glad you found and played though! I don't think I've met too many people who said Braums was their favorite, so that makes me happy x3 he's my favorite as well. And!! I'm so psyched to hear you played the BraumxParis route, haven't gotten a lot of feedback on that. Thanks for commenting ^^
I just finished Rafael's route and ughh I love this game so much! I played through Paris' route too, and loved it also!
I just want to say, that I loved every second of this VN. I knew it was going to be amazing when I saw the character's creation screen, the races are such a good idea and they're so different and interesting. I can't choose my favourite one, because I felt like all of them were very well done (I've played all three, but didn't finish a route with a Cubi yet). I really liked how Ash looked, too, they are very cute, and I really liked that you included pronouns and both genders, as well as different eye and hair colors. Oh, and the outfits were so pretty.
I really appreciate the fact that the changes in dialouge, depending on a race, are huge. The story and the world created felt so much more immersive. It also made me want to replay the game immediately, and that rarely happens to me! I liked the way the good choices were shown after making a choice, because that made the whole VN fun to play, I didn't have to be stressed out over not ending up with the ending I wanted.
Also, you have a really great writing style! I was laughing and smiling almost all the time, and I wasn't expecting that haha. The humor is just amazing, and the dialouge seems so natural and unforced. Honestly, this is one of the best writing I've seen in a visual novel, and I play a lot of them lol. And the plot twist with Rafael was really unexpected to me, I just sat there with my mouth open, you really got me good.
The fact that the whole game was free is just... wow.
Thank you so much for the nice comment! I'm so flattered to hear you enjoyed the writing so much. I really wanted this to be a more laid-back experience, so hints seemed the way to go. I want to say more but all the compliments have me flustered Dx
Thanks again for the lovely feedback c:
As a vegetarian I am offended by MC (but actually i just started playing the game and I like it so far)
Would anyone know how to unlock endings 5 and 7? (also if anyone knows how to get CG 13, 18 and 19? I'm stumped on those too lol)
End 5 is unlocked if you have low rafael points on his route by the end of the game, I believe end 7 is what happens if you have low paris points on his route...those two endings both have CGs, so that's probably where you're missing them. And I think CG 19 is unlocked after viewing the secret route!
hi I just love love this game so much!! But I'm having trouble with Braums route. I tried his route as a reaver or shika but it always seems to randomly select Paris as a reaver or Rafael as a shika or cubi. Please help I really would appreciate it. Thank you
That's bizarre! Can you give me a little more detail about what happens after you click on Braum's route?
Well when I try clicking on Bramus it just either clicks on Paris or Rafael when I play as a reaver or shika. I don't know if I'm doing something wrong. Is it the choices I'm making at the beginning of the story? It's too bad that I can't play his route. Anyway I already finished with Paris and Rafael T_T
No, the choices at the beginning don’t affect which route you’re on. When playing as a reaver, only Braums and Paris should be highlighted, so it shouldn’t be possible for Rafael to be clicked. How do you know which one the game is clicking on after you choose Braums?
usually the game just clicks on Paris for me when I try to click on Bramus. I tried a couple of times to choose him but still clicks on Paris
I haven't heard anyone else say they have this issue, so I'm not quite sure where to start, but I'll do my best to figure it out in the next update. In the meantime, I'd suggest redownloading the game if you haven't already. Sorry about this!
Some troubleshooting, is this the screen you see when playing as a reaver?and hovering over Braums should look like this:
Then it should go straight to the chapter 1 screen.
I love this game so much! It's wonderful, has lots of choices and custimization. I've done two and a half playthroughs so far!
Hey, I really like the game so far, but I have a small request: Can you make it so the emotion icons pop up what emotion they stand for when you mouse over them?
In the next update, I've added the tutorial screen to the CGs page so it can be reviewed at a moment's notice. Hopefully that will help!
ahh I'm scared to do the bad endings bc I never like getting them ;_; This VN is so pretty and fun, though!
Yeaaaah I feel you. This game really only has one "bad" ending though, so hopefully that'll make things easier to bear!
I laughed SO much throughout the game - this was fantastically and very humourously written!
Playing Shika is awesome! I'll try the other races eventually - haha
The game's cool, I just started playing it like 40 minutes ago. The thing is... Apparently I couldn't choose Paris route? Is it a glitch, did I do something wrong, or is he the last route to play? Thanks!
Anyone else decided that playing as a Shika (female) was definitely and interesting choice?
It's not a glitch, Paris can only be romanced by reaver or cubi Ash. You can romance Braums and Paris as a shika!
Excellent game! Now I'm waiting for a sequel that I now realize that I can't say anything about because it's so spoilery, lol